It’s a tough miniseries, but you persevere! Welcome back. Toes will almost assuredly be stepped on today, though that is not the goal! I hope you will stick with it through the end. Both Israel’s and America’s elections have left messy truths to discern, but God has not left His throne, so we always end with that encouragement!
America was dealt a huge blow on September 10, 2025, when a young man filled with evil hatred decided to take out not just an American icon, but one of only a few Americans who kept a balanced perspective of American politics while keeping Godly principles at the forefront. Charlie Kirk was not a perfect man, but he packed an influence that has not, and may never be, replaced.
Charlie was opposed to war, but also had deep understanding of God’s calling upon Israel, and the existential threat they faced from evil regimes such as Iran. He had a way of melding the distaste for war with a Christian’s responsibility to stand with Israel. He did not agree with everything the Israeli government did, and he spoke out about it. But he did take the Word of God seriously.
Charlie was a natural leader, particularly among young adults, and his death left perhaps a bigger void than we will ever realize. Charlie was able to rally otherwise liberal-leaning young people to consider conservative ideas, and he put them at the center. Kudos to Charlie for his ability to walk the tightrope between young people steeped in radical ideology on university campuses and conservative values that he espoused. It is a well-known fact that young voters (particularly males) played a very significant part in getting Donald Trump re-elected in 2024. In fact, to hear it told, young people “won it for Trump,” while baby boomers failed to show up and vote conservatively as strongly as in the past. (They were not totally wrong.)
Yet, in 2026, young voters retreated to their pre-2024 positions, leaning 55-60% progressive, while boomers were one of the few stable conservative voting blocs in 2026. Unfortunately, the movement Charlie Kirk created seems to have lost traction after his death. Why is that?
With care and intentionality, I have attempted to discern what I see. Understand, I have been a supporter of TPUSA and Charlie’s efforts, and believed the youth of America had a true freedom-loving, conservative leader worth following. However, I see great cause for concern now that Charlie is gone. I pray every day to be proven wrong, but it seems not only that leadership is lacking, but what is there seems to be leading in the wrong direction. Here are some observations that concern me:
- TPUSA is leaderless. I love Erika as a person and as a sister in Christ. I even admire her willingness to step into an incredibly difficult role. But is she anything more than a figurehead and a grieving widow with the sympathy of the White House? As CEO, is she capable of creating and using the momentum of a conservative youth movement to make noticeable change in our culture (or to even maintain what was there)? If so, why did so many young people turn back to progressivism?
- Concerns regarding other TPUSA leaders are perhaps more concerning. Some of their most influential social media influencers seem to be fostering an attitude of whining and complaining among young people. True, the economy is not the greatest for young people right now, but is $4/gallon gas worth handing over our government to those who wish to destroy our nation? The complaint runs up and down the age spectrum, so it is an issue at all ages. (BTW – gas is 10 shekels/liter in Israel and young and old alike are resourceful in dealing with the economic reality.) Yet, Charlie Kirk had a way of helping young people find a path forward and fight for what they want America to be. Now, it seems the podcasters dwell on how badly young people have it. Americans are spoiled (at all ages) and the influence of TPUSA’s leadership does our young people no favors by perpetuating the attitude of “oh poor me.” Every American, regardless of age, must be willing to do the next right thing to make our country better. Kudos to those young people who do not fall for in the pity trap, but work their tails off to forge a better America. We need more of that!
- Perhaps most concerning are the growing anti-Israel sentiments being perpetuated by TPUSA darling JD Vance and influencers such as Jack Posobiec and Benny Johnson, all of whom profess salvation in Jesus Christ. None have come out with specific antisemitic statements, but each has taken stances and made statements that clearly undercut America’s responsibility to stand with Israel. In the face of constant threats from Iran and their proxies to wipe Israel from the map, all three retreat from standing with Israel. JD Vance was the mastermind behind the sudden ceasefire just as Israel and the US had the opportunity to finish the job in Iran. Posobiec and Johnson want to simply “declare victory and pull out of the Middle East.” All are pushing for the Trump administration to isolate America and deal only with domestic issues. (“America First” or “America Only”?) If they think gas prices are high now, wait until America leaves the Strait of Hormuz and Iran regains control! Furthermore, Iran has already proven they have greater ballistic capabilities than previously known, and the drive to harden all nuclear facilities to protect against future destruction. The pathway to nuclear weapons would then be free and clear. Israel is not Iran’s final goal. They are only the appetizer. If Iran is left to achieve nuclear capabilities, they are coming for both Israel and America!
- We’ll talk about Israel’s importance to the US tomorrow, but for now, suffice it to say, many (including spokespersons at TPUSA) have harped on the aid package the US provides to Israel and are adamant to cut off all aid to Israel. That can be done, but we need to be careful what we ask for! (Tune in tomorrow to find out why!)
- As young and old alike drift from the Biblical mandate to stand with Israel, America is in deep need of those who will point young people in the right direction. It does not require agreement with everything Israel does, or that we bend to every whim. But we must recognize Israel’s right to exist and the existential threat they face by enemies on all sides. No youth movement is better positioned to take up that mantle than TPUSA, but sadly, it seems they are turning from that position. Charlie seemed to understand it. Unfortunately, it is hard to find anyone else at TPUSA who does.
This is not about knocking a great organization. TPUSA still does more for conservative youth than any other organization I know. But cracks are seen in the armor as legitimate concerns are left unaddressed. Will you pray for TPUSA and their leadership? May God grant them tremendous wisdom and favor to properly and Biblically lead our young people.
So what happens now? We lean not on earthly leaders or organizations to save us. Though they may provide righteous guidance, salvation is only through the Lord Jesus Christ. Charlie Kirk was a wonderful, Godly man, but he wasn’t God. The leaders of TPUSA, our churches, and conservative movements can be great mentors and leaders, but they cannot save us. Our faith must be in Christ alone.
Evil is upon us. It lingers around every turn and awaits its opportunity to overtake us. Yet, God’s Words says:
Trust in the Lord with all your heart,
And lean not on your own understanding;
6 In all your ways acknowledge Him,
And He shall direct your paths.
7 Do not be wise in your own eyes;
Fear the Lord and depart from evil.
8 It will be health to your flesh,
And strength to your bones.
~Proverbs 3:5-8
Our own understanding is to withdraw into ourselves, yet God’s Word teaches us to look outwardly. If we are to bless Israel and stand strong with her, we cannot retreat into our own shell, looking out only for our own best interests. Our own wise eyes will lead us astray and right into the arms of evil. In the end, every nation will be judged according to how they treated Israel. (Joel 3:2)
I don’t know about you, but I really want America to pass that test! Young and old alike need leaders who are bold enough to stand when others do not. Let’s be leaders in our own sphere of influence and stand shoulder to shoulder with Israel, and strong in the power of our God!
Tomorrow: Israel’s Importance to the US. Be sure to tune in. You may be surprised by what you read!